Federal magistrate Judge Teresa Stokes faced scrutiny after releasing Decarlos Brown Jr., a 34-year-old with a history of violence and schizophrenia, just months before he fatally stabbed Iryna Zarutska, a Ukrainian woman, on a train. Brown, who had been arrested over a dozen times for offenses including armed robbery and assault, was let out on a “written promise” to return for court appearances despite his dangerous tendencies.

The judge’s decision drew sharp criticism, as Brown had previously admitted he would kill again if released. During an arrest in January 2023, he told police he believed “man-made” materials were controlling his movements, leading to a volatile encounter that resulted in his detention. Despite this, Stokes allowed him to walk free, citing his promise to appear in court.

Brown’s criminal history included assaulting his sister in 2021 and being hospitalized for mental health issues after his mother secured an involuntary commitment order in 2014. His mother later criticized the system for failing to protect the community. Stokes’ release of Brown occurred despite his status as a flight risk, with no fixed address.

The case has raised questions about judicial accountability, particularly as Stokes also serves as director of a mental health treatment facility in Charlotte. Critics speculate whether her decision to free Brown could be linked to sending him to taxpayer-funded care at her own institution. The tragedy underscores the consequences of releasing individuals with severe criminal records and untreated mental illness, leaving a vulnerable victim in its wake.